A recent legal victory for Shopify against notorious patent troll Express Mobile sheds light on a troubling issue facing small businesses: patent infringement claims that can cripple their operations. The retraction of a $40 million verdict against Shopify reveals both the risks and the potential strategies for small business owners in an increasingly hostile landscape.
Shopify’s battle against Express Mobile highlights a significant concern for entrepreneurs. Patent trolls—entities that acquire patents solely to pursue litigation rather than to produce or innovate—have become a pervasive menace. According to Shopify, these trolls extract an estimated $29 billion annually from American businesses, and the numbers could be even higher today when adjusted for inflation.
In this particular case, the jury initially found Shopify liable for infringing overly broad web-design patents. Many small companies in Shopify’s position might have opted for a quick settlement, fearing the lengthy, costly litigation that often ensues. However, Shopify took a different approach. Instead of succumbing to pressure, it decided to fight back. They not only successfully overturned the jury’s verdict but also made Express Mobile pay them for their legal costs.
Jessica Hertz, Shopify’s general counsel, emphasized this proactive approach: "We’ll invest more effort fighting a frivolous claim than it would ever take to settle one. Not because we love litigation… but because trolls frequently target entrepreneurs that can’t afford to fight. So we do."
For small business owners, the implications of this victory are profound. It demonstrates that fighting back against patent trolls is not just possible; it’s a viable strategy. Many companies may feel trapped by the costs associated with legal action, often leading them to settle cases they would otherwise contest. Shopify’s experience illustrates that persistence can yield favorable results, potentially deterring future claims not only against itself but also throughout the business community.
However, the battle against patent trolls is fueled by significant challenges. Entrepreneurs often face the daunting reality of legal fees that can quickly outpace any potential settlement. The asymmetry between large corporations that can absorb legal costs and small businesses that may not have the resources to engage in protracted legal battles serves as the backbone of the troll business model. Shopify’s decision to wade into litigation could be risky for other, less resourced businesses.
Shopify’s fight against patent trolls also unearths larger systemic issues. The infrastructure supporting these trolls—entities like Acacia Research and IP Edge—operates largely unfettered by scrutiny, often hiding behind shell companies. This lack of transparency can leave small business owners vulnerable to opportunistic lawsuits. As Shopify continues to expose these hidden funders and advocate for legislative reform, it raises awareness for the broader community about the need for systemic change.
While Shopify’s recent legal victory is encouraging, it is crucial for small business owners to remain vigilant. The threat of patent litigation is a reality that can emerge without warning. Engaging with organizations dedicated to fighting patent trolls, like Unified Patents and the LOT Network, provides a layer of support for businesses seeking to defend their innovations.
In 2026, Shopify plans to maintain its firm stance against patent trolls—committing to invest in legal action that aims to dismantle this predatory system. Their approach serves as a reminder that as detrimental as patent trolls can be to small businesses, a united front and an unwavering determination can help rebuild a landscape more favorable to innovation.
Entrepreneurs should take note: advocating against unjust claims and fostering a culture of resistance can make a difference. The example set by Shopify encourages small businesses not only to protect their intellectual property vigorously but also to stand together against those who threaten to undermine the spirit of entrepreneurship.
Businesses seeking more information on this topic can view the original post from Shopify here.
Image Via BizSugar
