In a significant legal development highlighting the risks associated with hiring undocumented workers, El Cajon-based San Diego Powder & Protective Coatings and its human resources manager, Karli Buxton, have both pleaded guilty to federal charges of employing individuals without authorization to work in the United States. Following a March 2025 worksite enforcement action, the company has agreed to forfeit $230,000 as part of a broader plea agreement.
This case serves as a compelling reminder for small business owners about the critical importance of maintaining compliance with immigration and labor laws. In the current climate, failure to do so can lead not only to financial penalties but also to potential legal consequences that could disrupt business operations.
The company’s admissions reveal a troubling pattern: under the guidance of its operations manager, John Washburn, who also pleaded guilty earlier this year, San Diego Powder & Protective Coatings frequently hired employees with fraudulent documentation. This issue is particularly grave given the nature of the company’s work as a government contractor, where employees often had access to sensitive locations such as military bases. This raises concerns about both compliance and national security.
U.S. Attorney Adam Gordon emphasized the implications for businesses, stating, “Here’s my advice to the business community and to the lawyers who advise them: enroll in IMAGE.” The IMAGE program, initiated by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, offers resources and guidance to help businesses strengthen their hiring, employment verification, and compliance practices. This proactive step could not only mitigate risks but also reinforce a company’s reputation within their industry.
The practical applications of such programs for small businesses are evident. Enrolling in IMAGE aids in creating a compliant workforce while minimizing legal vulnerabilities. Companies involved in contracting with the government or those working in sensitive sectors, like military or federal projects, should be especially vigilant. As part of the plea agreement, San Diego Powder & Protective Coatings has committed to participate in the IMAGE program and will employ the E-Verify system to verify the eligibility of all new hires for the next two years.
However, challenges persist. Small business owners must ensure they have the necessary infrastructure to implement these verification programs effectively. This could require investment in training for staff responsible for compliance with hiring regulations. Moreover, there’s the ever-present risk of handling fraudulent documents, which can complicate the verification process.
The pledges from the Department of Homeland Security also demonstrate the government’s focus on enforcing labor laws. “Worksite enforcement operations like these deter illegal immigration, ensure employer accountability, and protect the U.S. workforce,” remarked HSI Acting Special Agent in Charge Kevin Murphy. This reinforcement of accountability poses a warning for businesses that might be tempted to overlook hiring practices in pursuit of lower operational costs.
Another layer of concern arises from the nature of the work being performed by these employees. Special Agent in Charge Greg Gross from the Naval Criminal Investigative Service stated, “Bypassing required vetting processes… threatens warfighter safety.” This justifies the rigorous scrutiny from authorities and can place small businesses in a precarious position if not compliant.
For small businesses, the implications are clear: the integration of robust compliance practices is no longer optional but essential. Employing the tools provided by programs like IMAGE and utilizing E-Verify may seem daunting, but these measures serve to protect businesses from hefty fines and legal jeopardy.
As the stakes continue to rise, small business owners must remain vigilant. Ensuring a clear understanding of hiring protocols and the ramifications of failing to comply will safeguard not only their enterprises but also contribute to the broader effort of sustaining a lawful and secure workforce environment.
For more detailed information, you can access the original press release from the U.S. Department of Justice here.
Image Via BizSugar
